We met up for dinner in Rhinebeck. During dinner we discussed titles for this website and Joyce came up with, 'All of Us'. The food was pleasant but nothing extraordinary. One of my soft shell crabs was quite good the other had a tough shell. Tom thought his dinner was boring. Catherine had Veal Marsala, which she found pleasant. Joyce seemed to like her stew type of dish. It is a classic French restaurant and the menu pretty much stays the same year after year, even though they do have specials which still fit the profile of the restaurant closely. It is a small intimate restaurant, and very noisy, which bothered Joyce. They are in the process of expanding into the space next door which was, for many years, a newspaper and cigar store.